Bureaucratic boundaries for collective learning in industrial work

Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of the paper is to explore individual and collective workplace learning and the connections between them in the contemporary industrial work.

Design/methodology/approach

Two case studies were carried out in the Finnish package‐supplier sector. The research methods applied were standardized observations and qualitative interviews.

Findings

The cases show that the socio‐technical influences have created learning‐conductive work at the individual level, but failed to create optimal possibilities for collective learning. The still‐prevailing bureaucratic power relations prevent employees from fully contributing to collective learning and organizational development.

Research limitations/implications

Workplace‐learning research should study more rigorously the connections between individual and collective learning and, especially, the ways in which the prevailing power relations influence them. Integrating concepts from chaordic systems thinking to the workplace‐learning theory seems fruitful and could be pursued further.

Practical implications

In order to become organizations in which internal and external development may take place at the individual and collective levels alike, the case companies should directly address their shared mental models regulating employees' participation opportunities rather than leave those models to develop in a non‐reflected way.

Originality/value

The paper contributes to the field of workplace learning by presenting a conceptual model on sustainable development building on concurrent individual and collective learning. With the help of this model, founded on several theoretical traditions, strengths and weakness in an organization's approach to workplace learning can be detected.

Citation

Kira, M. and Frieling, E. (2007), "Bureaucratic boundaries for collective learning in industrial work", Journal of Workplace Learning, Vol. 19 No. 5, pp. 296-310. https://doi.org/10.1108/13665620710757851